Hi, there, Pastor Chuck! I checked out your blog and your church's site. I believe I can help you come up with a refreshing title and tag-line for your page! When I saw you follow Christ, I was even more eager to help :) I work for my church as well, though it's a different denomination (I'm guessing you are Church of Christ, if the Hoover page is correct?) In any case, leading people to Jesus is the point!
As for my skills in slogans, I am a pretty creative gal. I've worked in college ministry for about 5 years now, and I was the primary marketing person for our organization. I made a t-shirt a while back for our group, LTC, which stands for Leadership Training Class, and I added the tag "we need each other" and it had a line drawing of mountains on the front (mountains stand strong together). So hopefully this gives you an idea of what I can do.
Hope to hear from you, and I hope you find the title you desire! I would like to email a bit back and forth before coming up with a title just to make sure I get the vision of what you're looking for.