Commiserations to Krishley, whose previously submitted logo is virtually identical to the winner! Why bother asking designers to contribute, when most on here are putting in their hard work, both in terms of integration with the requests of the client and the very little liaison the receive in return, and to top it all off, you you award the prize to a complete 'clone'. I seem to remember Krishley's design was entered before themia? No offence to the winner, but this seems a little pointless to me. This is why contests should be sealed.
Exactly. I totally agree. The ideas for creation and the interpretation of design for all who wish to participate is to provide clarity and understanding of the needs of the client, but also for the client to liaise with the best candidates, and to help filter out, in a sympathetic way, those who have not made it to the next stage. Only by doing this will we see less disgruntled designers and more satisfied customers. We are here providing our services and it is only fair, as crOix89 says, to be clearer in the design approach and make the selective process better by shortlising fewer individuals to take things to the closing stages. Perhaps sealing contests at a later stage would make it more competitive between the fewer, best candidates. Only your feedback can help achieve this, so please reply if you agree with me.
12 years ago
12 years ago
HI ALL, IT WAS VERY HARD TO CHOOSE AS THERE WERE SO MANY GOOD OPTIONS BUT I ACTUALLY PREFERRED THE FONT THAT THELMA USED, SO THAT WAS MY DECIDING FACTOR. AND AFTER ALL, I AM THE ONE WHO IS PAYING AND I WAS HAPPY WITH IT CLEAN AND SHARP FINISH. VERY HAPPY. AND SORRY TO EVERYONE ELSE.